On December 3, 2025, at approximately 7 PM, Harrison Police officers were conducting surveillance of the QuickChek on Bergen Street due to recent shoplifting incidents. During the surveillance, officers observed Jeffrey Barnhardt, 71, repeatedly walking between the rear of the store and the food warmer area, placing condiments into his pockets. Barnhardt then concealed a box of chicken tenders valued at $5.00 and exited the store without paying.
Officers detained Barnhardt outside the store, confirmed with staff that no items had been purchased, and obtained surveillance footage of the shoplifting. Barnhardt admitted to taking the items and was placed under arrest for shoplifting. He was transported to police headquarters for processing.